If Music Could Talk

The land of rock doesn't seem to like rock. Pussies.

Heston wrote:The land of rock doesn't seem to like rock. Pussies.

All nations that didn't produce Kajagoogoo, please stand up.

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:The land of rock doesn't seem to like rock. Pussies.

All nations that didn't produce Kajagoogoo, please stand up.

ALL IS FORGIVEN, DR. CANADA.

Wolter wrote:

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:The land of rock doesn't seem to like rock. Pussies.

All nations that didn't produce Kajagoogoo, please stand up.

ALL IS FORGIVEN, DR. CANADA.

*HIGH FIVES FOR SOME, KAJAGOOGOO FOR OTHERS*

Heston could play the Zep card here with great effectiveness. But he won't.

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:The land of rock doesn't seem to like rock. Pussies.

All nations that didn't produce Kajagoogoo, please stand up.

They are too shy.

matedog wrote:However, the Alive version probably tops the Let It Be version for the reasons mentioned above - more rock.

This is true only if you're talking about Gene Simmons' stool. Which I can only assume you are, since the wrongness afoot has not yet collapsed this thread into a gravitational singularity.

I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

I nominate Ratty.

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

Been doing that on here for years. Some people just won't accept a polished professional rock performance over a second rate, pissed-up version that seems to have been thought out and executed in half an hour. The Replacements are cool though, therein lies the problem.

Heston wrote:

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

Been doing that on here for years. Some people just won't accept a polished professional rock performance over a second rate, pissed-up version that seems to have been thought out and executed in half an hour. The Replacements are cool though, therein lies the problem.

The discussion hasn't been that concentrated and aiming at persuasion. People have just been going with their basic preference. And in my case, your side has two obstacles: I don't like KISS and I do like the Replacements (albeit not a huge fan). But I'm willing to keep an open mind to a serious debate.

Heston wrote:

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

Been doing that on here for years. Some people just won't accept a polished professional rock performance over a second rate, pissed-up version that seems to have been thought out and executed in half an hour. The Replacements are cool though, therein lies the problem.

And when the pissed-up version thought out and executed in *less than* half an hour turns out superior anyway?. . .



. . .you can always sell a few more lots of breakfast cereal for people with syphilis.

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

Been doing that on here for years. Some people just won't accept a polished professional rock performance over a second rate, pissed-up version that seems to have been thought out and executed in half an hour. The Replacements are cool though, therein lies the problem.

The discussion hasn't been that concentrated and aiming at persuasion. People have just been going with their basic preference. And in my case, your side has two obstacles: I don't like KISS and I do like the Replacements (albeit not a huge fan). But I'm willing to keep an open mind to a serious debate.

Okay, I'm signing my own death warrant, but I'm in. Who wants to kick this motherfucking shitshow off?

Heston wrote:

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:

Dr. Medulla wrote:

Heston wrote:I'd love a neutral platform on which to perform the ultimate Black Diamond vote.

If you're serious, don't have it as a poll but rather invite a proper debate about the two versions between yourself and someone arguing for the Replacements (RP?).

Been doing that on here for years. Some people just won't accept a polished professional rock performance over a second rate, pissed-up version that seems to have been thought out and executed in half an hour. The Replacements are cool though, therein lies the problem.

The discussion hasn't been that concentrated and aiming at persuasion. People have just been going with their basic preference. And in my case, your side has two obstacles: I don't like KISS and I do like the Replacements (albeit not a huge fan). But I'm willing to keep an open mind to a serious debate.

Okay, I'm signing my own death warrant, but I'm in. Who wants to kick this motherfucking shitshow off?

Exquisite!